15 June 2022
Sir Mike Penning asks how a European Court can overrule the UK Parliament and British courts

Speaking in the debate on the last-minute delay to the flight relocating illegal immigrants to Rwanda, Sir Mike Penning highlights the UK’s long history of welcoming genuine refugees and asks how it is right that an out-of-hours judge in the European Court of Human Rights can overrule the UK Parliament and the British courts.

Sir Mike Penning (Hemel Hempstead) (Con)

Let me say from the outset that I know the shadow Secretary of State very well, and she is much, much better than some of the comments she came out with today.

I say to the Home Secretary that I was a child in school when people came to this country from Vietnam and from Hong Kong, as well as from Africa, but this is different. This Parliament is supreme, and our courts have said this is right. This is what the British people want us to do—control immigration in relation to those coming across in boats—so how is it right that this Court has overruled all our courts and this Parliament?

Priti Patel (The Secretary of State for the Home Department)

My right hon. Friend makes some very important points. He speaks of the generosity of our country, and I stand by that. I think this Government’s record speaks very strongly on supporting people from Afghanistan, Syria, Hong Kong, Ukraine, and the hundreds of thousands of people whom we have supported. He rightly speaks about our domestic courts in the same way as I did in my statement, and it is important to note that the courts have not challenged the legality of our policy.

Hansard